THE HISTORY

The History of Drew’s Bayshore Bistro

The story of Chef Andrew “Drew” Araneo, his Keyport roots, the kitchen mentors who shaped him, and a restaurant that found its way back after Hurricane Sandy.
Chef Drew in the bistro kitchen

From Keyport roots to a hometown bistro

Andrew Araneo grew up in Keyport, New Jersey, and discovered a love of cooking early in life. He trained professionally at Brookdale Community College in Lincroft, then gained experience at well-known New Jersey restaurants including Joe & Maggie’s in Long Branch and Whispers in Spring Lake.
In 2005, he opened Drew’s Bayshore Bistro in his hometown, just blocks from where he grew up. His food reflects the bold Cajun and bistro flavors he loves, with influences from the Gulf Coast and Low Country.

A chef shaped by the kitchens of New Jersey

Drew’s culinary education continued beyond Brookdale. A pivotal mentor was chef Joe Romanowski, known for Joe & Maggie’s Bistro in Long Branch and later Bay Avenue Trattoria in Highlands. Drew joined Romanowski’s kitchen after being encouraged by a culinary instructor to apply for a job.
Romanowski’s country-French approach, rigorous work ethic, and deep respect for flavor helped shape Drew’s cooking. Drew recalls learning everything from preparing duck and confit to building richly flavored soups. He credits those lessons as an important foundation for the cooking at the Bistro.

Hurricane Sandy: loss, resilience, and a Keyport comeback

Hurricane Sandy devastated Drew’s Bayshore Bistro. Almost everything was lost, and the business remained closed for roughly four months. Though an alternative location in Atlantic Highlands was offered, Drew wanted to remain in Keyport—the town where he had grown up.
Friends and neighbors organized a community fundraiser to help Drew reopen. The gathering raised approximately $17,000. Drew described being deeply moved by the people who showed up and helped the restaurant start again. The Bistro eventually reopened at higher ground in Keyport.

A hometown restaurant, rebuilt with hometown support

Voodoo Shrimp and the Bobby Flay Throwdown

One of Drew’s signature dishes, Voodoo Shrimp, took center stage when he faced celebrity chef Bobby Flay in a televised throwdown. Drew won the challenge, and the attention brought a remarkable boost to the Bistro.
For Drew, the dish is built around its deeply developed sauce: he explains that it begins with dark beer and takes hours rather than minutes to make. That care and patience have helped make Voodoo Shrimp part of the restaurant’s identity.

The people and place behind the restaurant

Drew’s story is inseparable from Keyport. His journey reflects local friendships, the dedication of his kitchen mentors, and the neighbors who supported him after Sandy. He has continued to share his interpretation of Cajun and bistro food in a town he proudly calls home.
Chef Drew’s full first-person account—covering his relationship with Keyport, his mentor Joe Romanowski, the challenges of Hurricane Sandy, and the Voodoo Shrimp throwdown—appeared in an Inside Jersey feature by Teresa Politano and is reproduced on the restaurant’s original website.
A LOCAL ORIGINAL

A Keyport original since 2005.

From culinary school and the mentorship of Joe Romanowski to rebuilding after Hurricane Sandy and the celebrated Voodoo Shrimp throwdown, Drew’s Bayshore Bistro has a history rooted in Keyport and in the community that helped it thrive.